Welcome to Buffalo Mercantile Company and Cafe
Nestled in the charming Buffalo Cove, North Carolina, Buffalo Mercantile Company and Cafe offers a delightful blend of history and flavor. Renowned for its warm, inviting atmosphere, this beloved spot serves fresh, delectable pizzas made from house-crafted dough and sauces. Patrons rave about the friendly service and rustic decor, making it a perfect retreat for a stress-free experience. Featured favorites include the garlic knots and generous burgers, all lovingly prepared with high-quality ingredients. With its historic roots and cozy ambiance, Buffalo Mercantile is not just a meal; it's an unforgettable journey back in time.
-
6353 Buffalo Cove Rd, Lenoir, NC 28645, United States Hotline: +1 828-758-9879
Nestled in the picturesque landscape of Lenoir, North Carolina, Buffalo Mercantile Company and Cafe stands as a captivating blend of history and flavor. Located at 6353 Buffalo Cove Rd, this charming eatery invites guests to step back in time while indulging in a delightful menu of comfort food. With a reputation for serving some of the best personal pizzas and mouth-watering hamburgers, it's no wonder that locals and newcomers alike find themselves drawn to this hidden gem.
Visitors often rave about the welcoming atmosphere, enhanced by friendly staff who make every dining experience a joy. As Traveler Hawk noted, the burgers and garlic knots are best enjoyed in-house, while others recommend taking a pizza to-go—ideal for picnics or cozy nights at home. The decor, rich with history, brings a nostalgic charm that complements the delicious offerings. Frank Lossiah describes the pizza as "delicious," highlighting the fresh ingredients and generous toppings that set it apart from chain restaurants.
Beyond the food, the warm hospitality showcased by the staff, as highlighted by Southern Soul Chick and Brianna Queen, adds to the inviting charm of the cafe. Their passion for great service is matched only by the quality of their menu, with standout items like the made-in-house pizza dough, pasta, and signature sauces. As Soraya DaCosta recommends, dive into a plate of garlic knots with a side of marinara for an unmissable treat.
In a world of fast-paced dining options, Buffalo Mercantile Company and Cafe stands out as a haven for food lovers seeking comfort in both the dishes and the atmosphere. With its short holiday hours, planning a visit becomes part of the experience, adding a sense of excitement to each trip. Whether you're a resident or just passing through, this delightful spot is worth the detour—bringing the flavors of rustic America back to life, one slice at a time.
Make sure to call ahead at +1 828-758-9879 to confirm operating hours and prepare for a delicious journey into the heart of Buffalo Cove.
We love visiting old stores. Buffalo Mercantile Co. & Cafe was perfect - small and historic. I had a personal pizza and Chris had a hamburger. Both were great.
My wife and I just moved to the area, and we were happy to see this place open. We enjoyed burgers and garlic knots in-house and ordered a pizza to go. The staff are friendly and we will definitely be back.
Awesome little place out in buffalo cove NC, friendly people all the way around .. if you need a stress free day and a step back in time, stop by give them a visit and try their pizza....you will be glad you did
I love this little country store! So much history in that place. The lady that runs it is super sweet and kind. And they have some of the best candy you can’t find anywhere there! This is a must stop anytime we head up to my aunt’s cabin.
Awesome place. It takes you back in time because of the atmosphere and the small history. Pizza is of the chain, meaning it is delicious. The ingredients was fresh and worth the wait. Go see for yourself.
Great little place, popped in for a bite to eat and thoroughly enjoyed it. Looks great with some interesting decor, food was good (had a pizza with generous toppings), staff were friendly and chatty. A bit off the beaten track but worth the effort to swing by.
I can't say enough about this place. It's certainly a hidden gem. The food is out of this world! The ladies working were wonderful to talk to. The whole experience was well worth the ride up. We'll definitely be back.
I've been wanting to visit this place for some time now, and I'm so glad I finally made it. This is a hidden spot, in the middle of nowhere, and yet, perfect location for an out of the way country store and restaurant. It's only 15 minutes from Hwy 268 / Happy Valley area. The food was delicious, the ambiance was super cozy and inviting, and the view from the back deck was calming. The pizza dough is made in-house as well as all of the pasta and pizza sauces. I highly recommend trying the garlic knots with a side of marinara sauce. So good! Holiday hours are short (see picture), so make sure they are open before making a trip out. Summer hours are 11-8 PM (Tuesday through Saturday).